Here's some recent reviews of '$12.99'. The first site listed, www.c0nsensus.com, is a website where anyone can submit a song to be reviewed, and it's gets sent to 5 different reviewers, selected at random. Each reviewer rates the song on a scale of 1-10, in several different categories. Right now, '$12.99' is the highest rated song on the website!
A couple more recent CD reviews;
Parrotheads Ramblings (yes, Jimmy Buffet fans like me too)